Somerset County Maryland paper endorses call to end prison-based gerrymandering

by Peter Wagner, November 24, 2009  

The Daily Times in Salisbury, Maryland on the Lower Eastern Shore, has endorsed a call for Somerset County to base future county legislative districts on the resident — not prison — population.

An NAACP- and ACLU-led group of county leaders and community members, called the Somerset County Task Force on Diversity, has called for the county to explore the possibility of disregarding the population at the state prison when the county next updates its county legislative lines after the 2010 Census. The local newspaper has endorsed this call because over 40 percent of the county’s population is African-American, but no African-American has ever been elected to the county commission. The county agreed to settle a voting rights lawsuit and draw a majority African-American district in the mid-1980s. Unfortunately, a new large prison in the remedial district resulted in the African-American resident population being split among multiple districts, leaving the county without a true majority African-American district.

Read the editorial for more:

Our View: Exclude inmates from voting district

The Daily Times (Somerset County, MD) November 24, 2009

The Voting Rights Act was adopted in 1965 to codify the 15th Amendment’s guarantee that throughout the United States, no one shall be denied the right to vote on account of race or skin color. Considered one of the most successful pieces of civil rights legislation every adopted by Congress, it was extended in 1970, 1975 and again in 1982.

You would not think that legislation was needed to ensure that the terms of an amendment to the U.S. Constitution will not be violated, but if you believe that, you are not taking into account the extreme emotions and prejudices that still accompany that issue.

In 1986, a Voting Rights Act lawsuit settlement in Somerset County included creation of District 1, the so-called minority district, to encourage the election of at least one African-American to the County Commissioners. In a county with a population that is roughly 42 percent African-American and 2 percent Hispanic, never once has that happened.

Here’s at least part of the problem: Eastern Correctional Institution is included in District 1, and its inmates account for two-thirds of the total district population. With another U.S. Census year on the horizon, a citizens task force in Somerset County is seeking to exclude the inmate population from the District 1 tally — but only for purposes of creating voting districts.

This Somerset County district, however, is different because it was created as part of a court settlement. The purpose of the district’s existence is to enable the election of an African-American member to the County Commissioners; its lines were drawn specifically to support that goal.

Creation of the district itself predated the existence of ECI by about a year.

The fact that 42 percent of the total population of District 1 is not eligible to vote at all should be taken under special consideration in this case, since that fact is likely skewing the numbers and possibly preventing the district from achieving the goal for which it was created.

ECI inmates should, of course, be included in the census, by virtue of the fact they are U.S. citizens and residents. But in a voting district created for a specific purpose that is likely not being achieved because the prison population skews the numbers to such a high degree, a separate population breakdown that excludes the inmates would be a more fair and reasonable way to achieve that end.

2 Responses

  1. melissa says, 8 hours, 36 minutes after publication:

    how dare anyone to think that those people in eci are not humans. there are a lot of young people in there who made mistakes.wasnt you once young.where is your heart? do you believe in forgivness.everyone deserves a second chance. remember they have all the same body parts you have and they are human and should be counted as human.

    1. Peter Wagner says, 8 hours, 56 minutes after publication:

      The people incarcerated at ECI are people and should be counted in the Census. But the question is where they should be counted. Unfortunately, the Census Bureau counts incarcerated people as if they were residents of the prison county, and that causes big problems for drawing legislative districts.

      Most of the people incarcerated at ECI should be counted at their homes back in Baltimore, but until the Census Bureau changes where people in prison are counted, preventing prison districts from using the prison populations to pad their districts is a good interim solution.

Tweet this page Follow @PrisonPolicy on Twitter Get our newsletter Donate Contact Us


Events

  • September 21, 2016:
    Executive Director Peter Wagner will be speaking at Claremont McKenna College in California. Details TBA.

Not near you?
Invite us to your city, college or organization.