Reform is about political power and fairness, does not affect funding

by Peter Wagner, February 7, 2010

A state-wide campaign is underway to end prison-based gerrymandering in New York State. Unfortunately, a misinformation campaign threatens those efforts. Today, the Elmira Star-Gazette in upstate New York printed
my letter to the editor:

Mayor Tonello is concerned that a bill to change how prisoners are counted for redistricting purposes would hurt Elmira’s budget. [" Officials: Changing how census counts inmates would hurt region", February 1] This concern is misplaced.

The bill under consideration, S6725, would adjust federal census data for redistricting purposes. It would not apply to any federal or state funding program. All it would do is ensure that the data used for redistricting by the state and in each county complies with the New York State Constitution’s definition of residence which declares that people in prison remain residents of their pre-incarceration addresses.

Ironically, the proposed bill would put New York State’s practice in line with that of Chemung County. Rather than draw a county legislative district that was 30% prisoners — and give residents near the prison more influence over county affairs — Chemung County decided to adjust the Census, ignore the prison population, and draw fair county districts.

Like the proposed bill in the Senate, Chemung’s decision to draw fair districts without the prison population had no effect on federal or state funding. But it was a very good thing for democracy.

Peter Wagner
Executive Director, Prison Policy Initiative
Easthampton, Mass.

One Response

  1. Census Bureau’s prison count won’t mean funding windfall | Prisoners of the Census says, 1 month, 3 weeks after publication:

    […] state-level campaigns to fix the prison census for redistricting purposes are being hit by ridiculous claims that somehow state level claims will change federal funding formulas. State (or federal) funding […]

Tweet this page Follow @PrisonPolicy on Twitter Get our newsletter Donate


  • May 15, 2018:
    Our Policy Analyst Lucius Couloute will be at the LEDA Summit on Race and Inclusion in Holland, Michigan, presenting his research on the challenges and disadvantages people face when they are released from prison. Tickets are available on LEDA’s website.

Not near you?
Invite us to your city, college or organization.